feature storyfrom | the Financial Timesthe Lunch with the Financial Times interview.
June 1, 2022
IMAGE
— contents —
~ about
~ feature story
from: the Financial Times
column: Lunch with the Financial Times
story title: Breakfast with the Financial Times: Ray Kurzweil
deck: Over a specially prepared breakfast, the inventor + futurist details his plans to live forever.
author: by Caroline Daniel
date: April 2015
read | story
the Financial Times | home ~ channel
tag line: The world’s leading global business publication.
column | lunch with the Financial Times
campaign | Letters to this new world.
presented by
Nikkei | home ~ channel
tag line: The voice of the Asian century.
about | the column
by the Financial Times
The popular column — Lunch with the Financial Times — is a weekly interview with leading cultural + business figures.
It’s been published continuously since year 1995. Each interview includes a hand-drawn portrait by the famous caricaturist James Ferguson.
watch | thinking spaces w. James Ferguson
image | left
A caricature portrait of Ray Kurzweil, created especially for the interview.
credit: by James Ferguson
FEATURE STORY
An introduction.
The location of Ray Kurzweil’s San Francisco apartment must be kept confidential, warns his aide, for “important security reasons”. But I can disclose details of the breakfast that the writer, inventor and pill-taking futurist will prepare according to precepts in his 2009 book Transcend: 9 steps to living well forever. Kurzweil, who invented the first print-to-speech reading machine for the blind, the flatbed scanner and a music synthesiser capable of reproducing the sound of a grand piano, has been thinking about artificial intelligence (AI) for 50 years.
In the Age of Intelligent Machines (1990), he predicted the internet’s ubiquity and the rise of mobile devices. The Singularity is Near, his 2005 bestseller, focused on AI and the future of mankind. In 2012 he joined Google as a director of engineering to develop machine intelligence. Kurzweil’s supporters hail him as “the ultimate thinking machine” and “the rightful heir to Thomas Edison”.
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates has called him “the best person I know at predicting the future of artificial intelligence”. To his critics, he is “one of the greatest hucksters of the age”, and a “narcissistic crackpot obsessed with longevity”. Kurzweil greets me at his door. He is a slim, short man with a genial, baffled manner. Casually dressed in a blue linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves, he shakes my hand with soft hands covered in gold rings (one is from Massachusetts Institute of Technology; another I mistake for a Superman ring is the insignia of the Singularity University he co-founded).
At home with Ray.
His hair is darker than in earlier photographs and he looks like a nerdier brother of Woody Allen. We walk past a Kurzweil music synthesiser, a picture of the White Rabbit from Alice in Wonderland, before arriving in his living room in front of faintly unsettling Monet and Van Gogh paintings — “highly realistic 3D reproductions, done with a laser computer”, he says.
I contemplate a small table set with white china and paper napkins. There is a bowl of berries; a plate with smoked salmon and mackerel; six pieces of dark chocolate; a carton of vanilla WestSoy milk, a pile of Stevia sachets, and a bowl of tepid, dense porridge, that will remain largely uneaten by me. “Cocoa is anti-inflammatory and it’s very good for you. So that’s very dark chocolate with some espresso in. Berries, soy milk, unsweetened. Fish and green tea,” he says, pointing out each item. He eats almost no meat, is pescatarian and favours “healthy carbs and healthy fats. So a healthy carb is a little bit of berries, oatmeal, vegetables.”
Breakfast, including berries, fish, green tea, stevia and dark chocolate. Unnerved by this surreal meal, I find myself gazing at two cat-shaped salt and pepper pots, and ask: “Do you have lots of cat-related objects?” It is not the first question I had planned to ask of a genius but, as he pours me some green tea, he replies, perfectly contentedly: “Yes, I actually have 400 cat figurines. There’s only a handful here. That’s just a bit of whimsy. I do like cats. They’re very elegant creatures.”
He had 2 cats for 18 years. “They slept arm in arm. One was the father of the other but I don’t think they understood that relationship. So, like an old married human couple, when one died the other died a few weeks later. When the cats died, my allergies went away. So, being the very smart person that I am, I realised: I’m allergic to cats. So I haven’t replaced them. I also travel a lot.”
Just a few minutes into our meal, he departs to fetch a DVD about himself — the film Transcendent Man — and five tomes written by him. Including The Singularity is Near — he says is his most influential book.
“The Singularity group is based on it.” He opens it. “So this is where I talk about the neo-cortex, and that accounts for me being in Google — because I gave a pre-publication version to Larry Page (Google co-founder).
“He really liked it. That was 2 years ago now. I asked him for an investment in a company I would start based on these ideas, and he said: Sure we’ll invest, but let me convince you to do it here because we have Google-scale resources — data, computers and talent.”
Daily pills.
Barely minutes into our breakfast we have covered incestuous cats, AI — and how to get a job at Google. As his hand hovers over the berries, I tell him I’m disappointed not to see his bag of pills. He used to take up to 250 a day, now it’s 100. “I’ve found more bio-available forms. So instead of taking 10 pills I can take 2.”
He has already taken his morning intake of 30 pills — he later shows me a typical bag of them — including ones for “heart health, eye health, sexual health and brain health.” I ask how much this regime costs. “It’s a few 1,000 dollars a year. But it’s not one size fits all. A healthy 30 year-old might just need basic supplements.”
— breakfast —
location: Ray Kurzweil’s apartment
in: San Francisco, California
- blackberries
- raspberries
- smoked salmom
- smoked mackerel
- dark chocolate
- vanilla soy milk
- porridge
- green tea
30 morning pills — his daily intake includes coenzyme Q10, lutein and bilberry extract, glutathione IV, vinpocetine and pyridoxal 5-phosphate) Total: Complimentary His wife Sonya, a psychologist, and children, Ethan, 34, and Amy, 27 — also follow supplement regimes.
Making little headway with the unappetising mackerel, I stick to the berries. Kurzweil also isn’t eating much. I ask if he likes food. “I actually enjoy all food.” Then he reverts to science mode. “This food actually fills you up with fewer calories.” His interest in health goes back to when he was 15 — and his father Fredric, had a heart attack. “He died when I was 22. He was 58.” Kurzweil realised he could inherit his father’s dispositions. In his 30s, he was diagnosed with type-two diabetes. Frustrated by conventional treatments, he “approached this as an inventor”.
It has not returned. “You can overcome your genetic disposition. The common wisdom is it’s 80 per cent genes, 20 per cent lifestyle. If you’re diligent, it’s 90 per cent intervention and 10 per cent genes,” he claims. Though the 67-year-old Kurzweil looks fresh-faced (he uses antioxidant skin cream daily), he is ageing, even if his “biological age comes out in the late forties. It hasn’t moved that much.” But this is peanuts compared with Kurzweil’s ultimate goal: to live forever. That means staying healthy enough to get to what he dubs:
- bridge 2 — when the bio-tech revolution will re-programme our inherited biology
- bridge 3 — molecular nano-tech enabling us to rebuild our bodies.
Radical life extension has been on Kurzweil’s mind for decades. Today such sci-fi heroics to save mankind from death are being embraced by Silicon Valley’s tech elite. Billionaires such as Peter Thiel, PayPal co-founder, call death “the great enemy”; death is no longer seen as inevitable but as the latest evil to be “disrupted”.
Google, too, has created a separate venture, Calico, to combat ageing. “I had a discussion two years ago with the head of Google Ventures about longevity. It resulted in Calico. I’m an adviser. Ray Kurzweil’s morning intake of 30 pills “I think every death is tragic. We’ve learnt to accept it, the cycle of life and all that, but humans have an opportunity to transcend beyond natural limitations. Life expectancy was 19 a thousand years ago. It was 37 in 1800. Everyone believes in life extension.
Somebody comes out with a cure for disease, it’s celebrated. It’s not, ‘Oh, gee, that’s going to forestall death.’ ” A scientist in Newsweek magazine in 2009 mocked Kurzweil, saying his was “the most public mid-life crisis” ever. “These are ad hominem attacks. There’s what I call ‘death-ist’ philosophy of people who celebrate death,” he responds. Kurzweil claims the fundamental mistake his critics make is in believing progress is linear. T
his is his key thesis: “The reality of information technology is it progresses exponentially . . . 30 steps linearly gets you to 30. One, two, three, four, step 30 you’re at 30. With exponential growth, it’s one, two, four, eight. Step 30, you’re at a billion.” If medical progress might once have been a hit and miss affair, he argues that we are now starting to understand “the software of life”.
Data from the Human Genome Project will enable exponential, not incremental, progress. “Over the next 20, 25 years, we’re going to overcome almost all disease and ageing.” … Sitting with Kurzweil, he doesn’t sound crazed. His benign, amused tone is the same whether making bold predictions or discussing cats. He looks you in the eye and seems free of doubt. I’m curious about how he got to be him. Kurzweil tells me about growing up in a middle-class house in a suburban part of Queens, New York, with his father, a concert pianist and conductor, and his mother, Hannah, an artist. Ray Kurzweil’s collection of Tom Swift Jr books, one of his inspirations for becoming an inventor © Caroline Daniel One influence on his becoming an inventor was the series of Tom Swift Jr books, which he read, as a seven-year-old, at camp.
His collection is on display. One book, from 1914, is presciently called Tom Swift and his Photo Telephone. “Usually the human race was in trouble along with him, and he would disappear into his basement and come up with some invention that saved the day.” Another important influence was his grandmother, Lillian Bader, who wrote a memoir, One Life is Not Enough (something that rings true for her grandson), about her life in Austria. The Jewish family fled in 1938.
When Kurzweil was five, in 1953, Lillian showed him her mechanical typewriter. “It had a deep influence on me, because here was this magical machine. You could take a blank piece of paper and turn it into something that looked like it came from a book. It was not like parlour magic. With technology, if you see how it works, it’s still magical.” In high school his first major invention was to programme a computer to analyse composers’ melodies and write original music in the same style. “It won these national contests.
I got to meet President Johnson and took it on this TV show: I’ve Got A Secret. In 1970 he graduated from MIT with a degree in computer science and literature. More inventions followed. The blind singer-songwriter Stevie Wonder became the first person to own the Kurzweil reading machine. “The most gratifying has been the reading machine for the blind. I started on that in 1973 and I’ve been working continuously on it. The thrill of inventing is the leap from dry formulas on a blackboard to positive changes in people’s lives.” … Kurzweil may see into the future but he is also obsessed by his past. He pulls out his father’s PhD thesis on Brahms from 1938 and recounts a Brahms concert Fredric put on in Vienna in 1937.
A wealthy Philadelphia woman in the audience was so moved, she told Fredric: “If you ever need anything, let me know.” Following the Anschluss in March 1938, she sponsored his move to America. “You could say that Brahms saved his life.” The thrill of inventing is the leap from dry formulas on a blackboard to positive changes in people’s lives He remains mesmerised by his late father. “He was generally painfully shy and quiet but when he conducted he was ‘Maestro’ and there would be a party afterwards and everyone would go, ‘Maestro!’ And he’d take his hat off and . . . And he was quite brilliant.”
He has hundreds of boxes filled with his father’s documents. “I have all of his letters, and even his electric bills. There are 8mm movies, photographs, lots of vinyl records of his music. So the ambition is to create an avatar based on all that information that would reflect my father’s personality.
He would be indistinguishable from the real Fredric Kurzweil to the people who remember him. This avatar will be more like my father was than he would have been, had he lived (and was now 102).” It is evident that it is a very particular version of father he wants to recreate. The one he was at 58. “Yes,” he concedes. “My relationship with him deepened later in his life. He was very busy when I was a young child. [But] in my teenage years he was ill and was home a lot, and we had opportunity to talk about music, and artificial intelligence.” What would you want to ask, I hesitate, feeling uneasy using the word “him”? “I’d like to continue the conversations on music and the relationship of music to life and philosophy and math.” He predicts that by 2029 a computer will reach human levels of intelligence. Making progress on this avatar could depend on his work at Google on natural language understanding. A goal is to enable someone to have “a dialogue with a computer; it could be given a personality and a knowledge base.”
However, in a 2012 New Yorker article entitled “Kurzweil’s dubious new theory of mind”, Gary Marcus, a professor of psychology at New York University queried whether the mind is a hierarchical-pattern recogniser. He also argued Kurzweil ignored too much human psychology and irrational behaviour. Kurzweil’s work at Google aims at moving search beyond keywords towards more complex ideas.
He offers this example. “I met this girl at a party last night. We only spoke a few words but I felt an instant bond with her. Is that realistic? What does the psychology literature say about this? Ultimately, and this is the long-term project, it would be like asking a person who has reviewed the relevant literature and would intelligently give you the right citations and summarise them for you.” Artificial intelligence faces a battle from technologists, too such as Elon Musk, for example, who has called AI “our biggest existential threat”.
Alert to its perils, Kurzweil is frustrated at how AI is misrepresented in movies as a dangerous force divorced from humans, “an alien invasion of intelligent machines”. He sees AI as a tool that will enable billions of us “to enhance our capacity. They’ll go from being in our pockets to inside our bodies and brains.” ‘I mistake one of his rings for a Superman ring – it’s the insignia of the Singularity University he co-founded’
He is at his most playful when imagining the future, such as advances in virtual reality. “We could be having this brunch in the Taj Mahal or on a Mediterranean beach, and you’d feel the warm moist air in your face and it would be very realistic. That’s going to happen over the next couple of decades.” He cites a 2001 Ted conference in which, using sensors to create an avatar of a female rock singer, he became “Ramona. My voice was turned into her voice. I sang [Jefferson Airplane’s] ‘White Rabbit’.
It was considered a drug song but drugs are just one technology to change reality.” Kurzweil slips some chocolate into his mouth before continuing. “I was a different person, a young woman. It really felt quite liberating. And then, obviously, you could be anyone. A couple can become each other.”
He seems equally thrilled to use an old technology, writing a novel, to create a character who immodestly articulates his own ideas. “It’s called Danielle, and it follows this young girl from zero to 22. Here she is in Zambia. She’s my fantasy of myself. She’s very precocious.” As I leave, I walk past his electronic keyboard and ask if he plays. “My repertoire is limited,” he admits. “It peaked.”
Surely, I joke, if he is going to live for ever he could be like Bill Murray in the film Groundhog Day who, unable to die, becomes an expert pianist (ice sculptor and French speaker). “There are so many things we could apply our minds to. That’s really the goal of artificial intelligence — to enhance our capacity.”
— end —